Guide

How to Choose an AI Automation Agency: A 10-Point Checklist

In short

Look for a clear scope and quote, named case studies with measurable results, a written security and data-handling approach, experience integrating with your tools, and ongoing maintenance after launch. Ask to speak to past clients, and be cautious of guaranteed outcomes or vague pricing.

The 10-point checklist

1

A clear scope and quote

Good looks like: A written scope, deliverables and price before work starts.

Red flag: Vague proposals, or “we will figure it out as we go”.

2

Relevant case studies

Good looks like: Named clients and measurable results you can verify.

Red flag: Only generic testimonials or unnamed logos.

3

Honest claims

Good looks like: Realistic outcomes, with the assumptions explained.

Red flag: Guaranteed results or promises of overnight transformation.

4

Security and data handling

Good looks like: Encryption, access controls and clear rules on what reaches AI models.

Red flag: No written approach, or reluctance to discuss it.

5

Integration experience

Good looks like: Has connected tools like yours through APIs or connectors.

Red flag: Insists you replace your existing software.

6

Ownership and portability

Good looks like: You own your workflows and can take them elsewhere.

Red flag: Lock-in with no way to export.

7

Maintenance after launch

Good looks like: A clear support plan with defined response times.

Red flag: A handover with no support.

8

Humans in the loop

Good looks like: Approvals on high-impact steps.

Red flag: Fully autonomous by default.

9

Communication

Good looks like: A named contact and regular updates.

Red flag: Slow replies even during the sales process.

10

Pricing transparency

Good looks like: Explains what drives cost and the options.

Red flag: Refuses to discuss pricing at all.

Questions to ask on the first call

  • Can you show me a similar project and put me in touch with the client?
  • What will you need from my team, and how many hours will that take?
  • How do you handle security and personal data?
  • What happens if something breaks after launch?
  • Who owns the workflows and any code you write?
  • How will we measure success?

Red flags to walk away from

  • Guaranteed outcomes with no assumptions
  • Pressure to sign quickly
  • No named references
  • No written scope
  • A one-size-fits-all package for very different businesses

How WunderWaffen approaches this

Every WunderWaffen project starts with a free 30-minute discovery call. The team publishes case studies with named clients, offers a Workflow Maintenance Subscription so automations are looked after after launch, and prices by retainer or project, with the option to switch between them.

Frequently asked questions

How many agencies should I compare?

Two or three is enough. Give each the same brief so the proposals are easy to compare.

Should I hire in-house instead?

It depends on volume and skills. Many companies use an agency to build and maintain, then decide later whether to bring some work in-house.

What should a proposal include?

A written scope, deliverables, timeline, price, what you need to provide, how success will be measured and what support follows launch.

How long should a first project take?

For one well-scoped workflow, a few weeks is typical. Be wary of anyone promising a full transformation in days, or a first project that runs for many months before you see anything working.

Who should own the finished automation?

You should. Ask where the workflows and code will live, and whether you keep them if you stop working with the agency.